New FDA Draft Guidance - Non Clinical Evaluation For Anticancer Pharmaceuticals

The FDA has produced some draft guidance aimedconsidered essential to support clinical use of an
at establishing an internationally accepted objectivesanticancer pharmaceutical. To support Phase I clinical
and / or recommendations on the design and conducttrials at least one nonclinical study should incorporate
of nonclinical studies to support the development ofa recovery period at the end of the study to assess
anticancer pharmaceuticals in patients with advancedfor reversibility of toxicity findings or the potential
disease and limited therapeutic options.that toxicity continues to progress after cessation of
Because malignant tumors are life-threatening, thedrug treatment. Toxicokinetic evaluation should be
death rate from these diseases is high, and existingconducted as appropriate.
therapies have limited effectiveness, it is desired toReproduction Toxicology - These studies are not
provide new effective anticancer drugs to patientsconsidered essential to support clinical trials intended
more expeditiously. Nonclinical evaluations arefor the treatment of patients with late stage or
intended to 1) identify the pharmacological propertiesadvanced cancer. These studies are also not
of a pharmaceutical, 2) establish a safe initial doseconsidered essential for pharmaceuticals which target
and 3) understand the toxicological profile.rapidly dividing cells in general toxicity studies or
These new guidelines only apply to pharmaceuticalsbelong to a class which has been well characterized in
intended to treat cancer in patients with late stage orcausing developmental toxicity. Generally no fertility
advanced disease regardless of the route ofstudy is warranted to support the treatment of
administration, including both small molecule andpatients with late stage or advanced cancer. A peri-
biotechnology-derived pharmaceuticals.and postnatal toxicology study is generally not
Studies to support nonclinical evaluationwarranted to support the treatment of patients with
Pharmacology - prior to phase I studies, preliminarylate stage or advanced cancer.
characterization of the mechanism(s) of action,Genotoxicity - Genotoxicity studies are not
resistance, and schedule dependencies as well asconsidered essential to support clinical trials for
anti-tumour activity should have been made.therapeutics intended to treat patients with late
appropriate models should be selected based on thestage or advanced cancer.
target and mechanism of action but need not beImmunotoxcity - For anticancer pharmaceuticals the
studied using the same tumour types intended fordesign components of the general toxicology studies
clinical evaluation. these studies can provide proof ofare considered sufficient to evaluate immunotoxic
principle, guide schedules and dose escalationpotential and support marketing.
schemes, provide information for selected testThe guidelines go on to describe how you can use
species, and aid starting dose selection.the pre-clinical data in designing you clinical trial: start
Safety Pharmacology - as assessment of vital organdose for first administration in man, dose escalation
function should be available before initiation of clinicaland the highest dose in clinical trials. the guidelines also
studies. Stand alone safety pharmacology studiesprovide guidance on duration and schedule of
need not be conducted to support studies intoxicology studies to support initial clinical trials, the
pateiutne with late stage cancer or advanced disease.duration of toxicology studies to support continued
Pharmacokinetics - the evaluation of limited kineticclinical development and marketing, how to manage
parameters, e.g. peak plasma levels, AUC and half lifecombination pharmaceuticals and Finlay the non clinical
in the animal species used for non-clinical studies canstudies to support trials in pediatric populations. Other
facilitate dose escalation during phase I.considerations addressed in the guidelines include
General Toxicology - The primary objective of Phaseconjugated agents, liposomal products, evaluation of
I clinical trials in patients with cancer is to assess thedrug metabolites, and evaluation of impurities.
safety of the pharmaceutical. This can include dosingTable - Example schedules for anticancer
to a maximum tolerated dose (MTD) and dose limitingpharmaceuticals to support initial clinical trials.
toxicity (DLT). Therefore, determination of a no(reproduced from FDA guidelines S9)
observed adverse effect level (NOAEL) or no effectIf you would like more detail in this area please get in
level (NOEL) in the toxicology studies is nottouch with Damien Bové damien.