The Myth of Universal Health Insurance

The entire national conversation on "Health CareWhy not reduce your bad test levels by doing natural
Reform" is based on the idea that if everyone justthings: daily oatmeal and vitamin C for cholesterol
had health insurance ("access" to "health" care) thenlowering; exercise/dietary changes and chiropractic
everyone would be healthier. Left unexamined in thisfor lowering blood pressure. The Journal of Human
assumption is where health actually comes from-doesHypertension published a medical peer-reviewed
health really come from health insurance?study demonstrating the reduction of high blood
Does fire insurance make you immune to fire? Doespressure by chiropractic care; the lead reviewer Dr.
auto collision insurance prevent damage to your car?Bakris had this to say:
No, insurance is simply a way to pay for correctingCompared to the sham-treated patients, those who
damage to your house/car/body after it occurs.got the real procedure saw an average 14 mm Hg
Health itself comes from doing things that aregreater drop in systolic blood pressure (the top
healthy, such as exercise, proper nutrition, adequatenumber in a blood pressure count), and an average 8
rest, pure air and water, positive mental attitude andmm Hg greater drop in diastolic blood pressure (the
of course a nervous system free of interference.bottom blood pressure number).
This is sometimes referred to as prevention, as inNone of the patients took blood pressure medicine
preventing illness before it starts, rather than tryingduring the eight-week study.
to correct it after the fact."When the statistician brought me the data, I actually
Much of the argument for universal health insurance isdidn't believe it. It was way too good to be true,"
based on the idea of preventative medicine, that it'sBakris says. " The statistician said, 'I don't even
cheaper to prevent illness than to treat it later. Whilebelieve it.' But we checked for everything, and there
this is undoubtedly true, just what medicalit was."
procedures do we have that actually prevent healthSo if preventative medicine doesn't offer prevention,
problems without causing other ones? Unfortunatelywhat's a body to do? You might consider doing as
the answer may just be: none. Let's look at some ofmy family and I have done for years: keep your
the ones usually used as examples of prevention.body's control system working well through regular
Vaccination is sold to prevent illness yet vaccineschiropractic care and exercise, with as much organic
cause so many illnesses (called side effects) that thefood as you can get, and pure water and air. We
federal government has been forced to give thehave not needed to take any medications during my
vaccine manufacturers immunity from lawsuits to35 years as a chiropractor, and we have not needed
ensure vaccine production. The Government Vaccinemedical services aside from first aid for any of our
Damage Compensation fund has paid out over $1.3family members during this time. We do not have
billion dollars in proven vaccine injuries over the lastaspirin, Tylenol, Aleve, Advil etc in our medicine
decade.cabinet. In fact, we don't even have a medicine
Medical checkups are used as another example ofcabinet-it's a bathroom cabinet! You can have a similar
prevention, but they do not actually prevent, butlifestyle if you like; it's easy and fun to have your
simply detect problems earlier, and lead to drugbody function well without any drugs!
regimens or surgical procedures if any abnormalAre we in favor of universal health insurance? Of
values appear. Recently the annual mammogram,course, as long as it actually insures we will have
probably THE preventive test in medicine, has beenhealth. Unfortunately, most plans only insure our
recommended against for women under 50, due tomedical visits, tests and surgeries will be paid for.
its failure to lower the death rates from breastMedicare is a plan that has been largely successful
cancer, and the high percentage of false positivesbecause the contributors to the system vastly
which cause unnecessary surgeries and complicationsoutnumber the recipients; that is about to change, as
therefrom, as well as anxiety, depression, and otherthe baby boomers enter their Medicare years (and
problems associated with mastectomy.may change even quicker if Congress alters it).
Cholesterol checks have become popular in manyMedicare covers chiropractic care fairly well, and the
medical practices, yet the cholesterol meds (statins)profession anticipates we will be covered in Medicare
have some of the worst, and best-documented, sideto an even greater degree as the doctor-shortage
effects in all the pharmacopeia. Liver damage isbecomes more acute in the next decade or two.
documented in 5% of statin users, andThe Muse and Associates 2001 Medicare Study of
rhabdomyolysis (muscle destruction) has beenchiropractic claims versus similar patients who did not
demonstrated in over half of all users. Further, it issee the chiropractor, was very revealing:
common knowledge that over 50% of fatal orBeneficiaries who received chiropractic care had lower
serious heart attacks occur in people with normalaverage Medicare payments for all services than
blood cholesterol readings. Obviously some factorsthose who did not ($4,426 versus $8,103). Yes, you
are responsible other than just "high cholesterol".read that right! Adding chiropractic care reduced the
"Statin drugs are known to inhibit our very importantaverage total medical bill by almost half! The obvious
production of coenzyme Q10. Importantly, whileconclusion: patients who see a chiropractor spend
many cardiologists insist that lowering cholesterol isless(much less) on medical care than the patients
correlated with a reduction in the risk of heartwho don't.
attacks; few can say that there is a reduction in theThe journal JMPT reported in 2000 that senior
risk of mortality (death). That has been much hardercitizens who had been under "maintenance" or
to show. In other words it has never beenwellness care for five years or longer had health care
conclusively shown that lowering cholesterol savesspending of only 31% of the national average and
lives. In fact, several large studies have shown thathad 50% fewer medical provider visits.
lowering cholesterol into the range currentlyWhatever enlargement of government-paid health
recommended is correlated with an increased risk ofcare occurs this year in Congress, chiropractic is likely
dying, especially of cancer."to be included, in some form.It's too vital not to be.
---Ron Rosedale,M.D.But you don't have to wait for Congress; you can
Blood pressure meds for asymptomatic patients?start or get back in the habit of regular chiropractic
The number one side effect of pressure pills iscare for a healthy productive and long life and you'll
reduction of blood flow in the extremities, includingbe able to say, like Senator Strom Thurmond (he
the head(and brain). Is this something to be desired?served as a US Senator until age 100) "I owe my
The listed side effects for your pills will scare youlongevity to daily exercise and chiropractic care".
senseless if you ever look them up.